Our community has so much to offer. Visitors and locals alike tend to gravitate towards downtown for shopping, dining, and recreational activities. Midtown is often overlooked, despite being home to many vibrant and community-oriented businesses. Today, we’re venturing beyond the Uptown Arts District to explore the hidden gems of midtown and the businesses located there.
Canterbury Theatre
This beloved institution has been providing entertainment in midtown Michigan City for over 56 years! The theater has become a cornerstone for creativity and the performing arts, offering the community a place to gather, be inspired, and experience theater. They are passionate about theater and believe in the power of live theatre to inspire, challenge, and entertain! They produce comedy, romance, and drama shows each summer. Their intimate 130-seat performance facility is even available to rent for the whole year except for June and July. This is definitely a hidden gem in midtown that’s worth a visit for theater lovers.
Learn more here: https://www.canterburytheatre.org/
Panini Panini
This cozy panini shop features a mix of classic European foods, such as sandwiches, pastas, and a variety of desserts. They have something for everyone, with their menu even including gluten-free and vegetarian options. This casual dining spot is in midtown Michigan City. Their food is made fresh daily, homemade, and handcrafted. Panini Panini offers a unique and worldly palate to midtown and is definitely worth visiting for foodies!
Learn more: https://www.paninipaniniin.com/
Albano’s Villa
Albano’s Villa is a local favorite with three locations, one of them being midtown Michigan City! The pizzeria has been around since 1957, when Jim Albano Sr. opened the very first Albano’s Villa. The restaurant began in their family’s home and has been using the same recipes and cooking methods ever since. Albano’s even started delivering pizzas and selling frozen pizzas in stores before it was common. With delicious pizza and a rich Michigan City history, this midtown classic is just waiting to be visited by locals and visitors alike.
Learn more: http://www.albanosvilla.com/home.html
Local Option
Local Option is another great restaurant to explore in midtown. Not to mention it’s a local business…it’s right in the name! Their friendly atmosphere, as well as their top-notch service, promise a lovely experience from start to finish. The restaurant has handmade pizza along with plenty of other menu items. Their deep dish is especially good and a local favorite. Be sure to check out this business and try their tasty bites!
Learn more: https://www.localoptionmc.com/
Social Que
This barbecue restaurant was started by Michigan City native, Brealon Hervey. Located in midtown, the restaurant uses unique barbecuing techniques to create a delicious and smoky barbecue. Social Que is a local favorite, with amazing service and high-quality food. They cater and have a sit-in restaurant. This is a great place for foodies and barbecue lovers to visit!
Learn more: https://socialquebbq.com/
The Cellar Door
Recently opening in the midtown of Michigan City, this establishment is more than just a bar. The Cellar Door offers a place to gather, connect, and share experiences. The restaurant has tasty food and craft drinks. It is housed in a historic barroom that dates all the way back to 1890. They even have games and a charming porch to enjoy your meal on. A midtown classic!
Learn more: https://cellardoorbar.com/
The Nightingale
This establishment is a speakeasy-inspired bar located in midtown. With lavish decor, timeless elegance, and exclusive charm, The Nightingale offers an unforgettable experience. The bar is complete with a doorman, a professional bartender, and a pristine Art Deco bar. The establishment features a private bowling alley available for rent with a dedicated bowling attendant to help with food and drink needs. This bar is a must-visit in midtown for an elevated and fun night.
Learn more: https://thenightingalemc.com/
Midtown has many local businesses waiting to be discovered! While we love supporting downtown, midtown has so many local gems. It is crucial to support local businesses and keep our community thriving.
